Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Cumberland County, PA & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Cumberland County, PA

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 9%
Liberty Mutual A 8.33%
Nationwide A+ 7.7%
Travelers A++ 6.47%
GEICO A++ 3.26%

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Cumberland County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Gary A Gibson Ins Agency Llc 28 Oakglade Dr
17036
(717) 566-6312
The Wiswall Agency Inc. 16A National Place
21157
Marla J Evans 1000 Millersville Rd. Ste A
17603
(717) 295-7665
The Merhar Agency Llc Po Box 10
17057
Gary A Dibileo Agency Inc 27 S 2nd St
17074
(717) 567-6060
Donald L Atwell Agency 150 Linglestown Rd
17110
(717) 541-4390
Malachy R Mcmahon Inc 19756 Longmeadow Rd
21742-2930
(301) 790-3304
Mark Raubenstine 2232 Shermans Valley Rd
17024-0040
(717) 582-7457
Samuel S. Pickens 13022 Pennsylvania Avenue
21742
Joann P. Belfiore 3215 MAIN ST
21102
410-239-6353

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Cumberland County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
John Kim 50 CANAL ST SUITE A
17057
717-944-0466
Gary Kelly 319 8th St
16652
(814) 643-6310
Kristi Hammond 19909 BENTLEY RIDGE CT
21120
443-878-7417
Amanda Aversa 1223 Bridge St
17070-1670
717-774-2517
Catalina Robbins 3790 Peters Mt Road
17032
717-896-4000
James Stenzel 1120 C PROFESSIONAL CT
21740
301-733-2530
Samuel P Breniman Lutcf 123 N Main Street Apt 202
17236
Thomas B Drechsel Lutcf 143 E Main St
21157
Michael Downey 683 S Main St
17356
(717) 244-9716
David Feighn 270 S. Progress
17109-4637
717-901-7000

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Cumberland County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Melissa Manikas 977 Rte 522
www.melissamanikas.com 17870
(570) 374-8101
Sam Morrill 31 S Main Street
www.morrillinsurance.net 17084
Gary Scott 3195a Cape Horn Rd
www.garyscottsf.com 17356
(717) 246-8488
Rhonda Mcmahan 32 W Main St
www.rhondamcmahan.com 17078
(717) 473-4476
John Dipace 718 ELLIOTT ST
www.johndipace.com 17243
814-447-5568
Mike Kelty 1120C PROFESSIONAL CT
www.mikekelty.com 21740
(301) 739-6400
Sean Sorensen 3530 Peters Mountain Road
17032
Mark Gudalis 63 N Main St Ste K
17363-0279
(717) 993-2300
Joann Graziano 3230 MAIDEN LN
www.joanngraziano.com 21102
410-239-4010
Joann Cuevas 3107 MAIN ST STE A
www.joanncuevas.com 21102
410-239-0720

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Cumberland County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
James Stevenson Insurance Group Llc 934 SWEENEY DRIVE STE 1
21740
410-465-5756
Gary L Price Agency Llc 201 Lincoln Way E
17233
(717) 485-5500
Email:gprice@garypriceinsurance.com
Selective Associates Inc 1231 E Chocolate Avenue
www.saiinsurance.com 17033
A R Keir Inc 95 Theater Ln
17402-2657
717-854-2592
Flag Insurance Services Inc 5021 E Trindle Rd
www.flaginsurance.com 17050
(717) 458-5553
Marian V Farese Agency 2398 SR 72
17038
(717) 865-7260
Davis Assoc Comm Ins 1826 N Susquehanna Trl
17404
(717) 845-4011
The Walter Rose Agency Inc 1501 N Front St
17102
Forbes Agency Inc 342a Market St
17061
(717) 436-7555
Email:g.forbes@forbesinsurance.com
Co West Of San Luis Valley 4190 Philadelphia Ave
17201-8939
717-709-1719

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Cumberland County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Matt Clegg 1505 West Market St.
17404-5561
(717) 843-3686
Email:mclegg@geico.com

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Cumberland County, PA

Liberty MutualTravelersGEICO
Median Home Value ($) 174,690184,690204,690
Construction year 198219851976
Home Coverage ($) $250000-$300000$250000-$300000$350000-$400000
Total Premium ($) $902$1355$1827

Cumberland County, PA Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Nationwide upto 5%
Liberty Mutual upto 18%
Travelers upto 7%
GEICO upto 24%